Why did Soldiers Fight in Lines? | Animated History

Ironside Computers - Click here to cutomize your own PC: ironsidecomputers.com/ **USE DISCOUNT CODE "History" FOR 5% OFF!**
Rode Microphones: Click Here to Purchase your Microphone: en.rode.com/ Also available on Amazon.com
History with Hilbert: trvision.net/detail/video--Mp1leRBfn8.html
Our Website: www.thearmchairhistorian.com/
Our Twitter: twitter.com/ArmchairHist
Sources/Music:
Warfare in the Nineteenth Century, David Gates
The Art of War in the Western World, Archer Jones
Music:
WIP
Thanks to everyone listed below for joining the stream:
MrHorstel
Carl Felldén
Kenstreme
Yahir Tapia
Meessen M
Saris
PetoSoldato
Chitransh Pawar
Aliyah Janet Valencia
Notji
Brandon Huynh
Griff or I will cut you
Dean Leyretana
Boris Kerelman

Herunterladen

YORUMLAR

  • Don't forget to check out Hilbert's channel! trvision.net/pass/UC1Zc6_BhPXiCWZlrZP4EsEg Ironside Computers - Click here to cutomize your own PC: ironsidecomputers.com/ **USE DISCOUNT CODE "History" FOR 5% OFF!** Rode Microphones: Click Here to Purchase your Microphone: en.rode.com/ Also available on Amazon.com Thanks for watching! Our Patreon: www.patreon.com/armchairhistory Our Twitter: twitter.com/ArmchairHist Our Discord: discord.gg/bzHGV3F Griff

    The Armchair HistorianThe Armchair Historian2 yıl önce
    • What 😂

      Mateo CadornigaraMateo Cadornigara4 aylar önce
    • ++000+0000

      Rob ChristianRob Christian6 aylar önce
    • Was there also close combat commun

      werewolf of the dark Wolfwerewolf of the dark Wolf6 aylar önce
    • Hey can you explain a little bit aboat the eastern tacticts such as ottomans or persia I'm beging you i need convince someone it's really important to me

      Vereenigde Oostindische CompagnieVereenigde Oostindische Compagnie8 aylar önce
    • You made me frown when you criticized "The Patriot." It's an awesome movie. I don't care if any of it isn't accurate historically. It's got a lot of awesome action scene's. And also Mel Gibson didn't single handily take out the British army. He and his two sons helped take out a small company of them guarding on of the characters older sons. They were trying to rescue them.

      Broken BridgeBroken Bridge9 aylar önce
  • The only way to repel massed Musketry was with massed Musketry, as you would not have the same density of firepower. After Napoleon's defeat, there was also a relative peace in Europe that lasted almost to the end of the 19th Century, and while weapons continued to be improved, the Tactics remained the same. It wasn't till the advent of wired communications and the radio, were Troops allowed to be dispersed along a line of battle, as Command and Control could then be maintained.

    C Ray StarlingC Ray Starling14 saatler önce
  • Because they were stupid and mindlessly following commands from the elite upper class.

    YakYakGün önce
  • concetrated > concentrated

    TMH LandscapesTMH Landscapes2 gün önce
  • Dude, you don't mention Polish Winged Hussars in that video. Sucks.

    Mariusz JagodaMariusz Jagoda4 gün önce
  • My grandma said it was so stupid how they use to just stand in lines and shoot at eachother. I was about to DESTROY her with FACTS AND LOGIC But instead I said "lol ya" Maybe next time...

    sloopsloop4 gün önce
  • Why did Soldiers Fight in Lines? So that you could actually hit your target. War''s always been a game played by the rich. Which is why savages use guerrilla warfare.

    BlackXIIIBlackXIII5 gün önce
  • The real question is why do they take enemies’ shots for free? It’s the part where 1 side is about to fire and the other side is just standing in formation... why didn’t the other side prone on the ground? Then get up once the opponent reloads

    Mythic Real TrapMythic Real Trap5 gün önce
  • che guevara: *guerilla wafare*

    Shawn ValverdeShawn Valverde6 gün önce
  • still doesn't make sense to me

    Zaki AzhariZaki Azhari6 gün önce
  • Gustavus was killed by Croatian not German cavalry.

    Hrcak1Hrcak16 gün önce
  • Interviewing a 17th century British veteran: "So how'd you survive the war?" "Um, I just had my friend's back"

    sir Nortonsir Norton8 gün önce
  • Apparantly, Empire Total War did quite well on their Tech Tree.

    Bart SomethingBart Something8 gün önce
  • because they love to play jrpg duh

    attack helicopter jrattack helicopter jr11 gün önce
  • So they’re easier to hit

    John DoeJohn Doe12 gün önce
  • What?!? No metion at all of the Spanish Tercios ?!? Inconceivable!

    Alejandro EsquivelAlejandro Esquivel12 gün önce
  • Idc if the historical accuracy is bad, the patriot rocks.

    Sam MurphySam Murphy13 gün önce
  • Um. The patriot is Flippin amazing

    Cars N Guitars Bret BuntonCars N Guitars Bret Bunton14 gün önce
  • 3:37 Is when he answers why soldiers fight in lines.

    Phillip JamesonPhillip Jameson14 gün önce
  • Because: *Reasons*

    Akram GimminiAkram Gimmini20 gün önce
  • You know, everytime I see a video about Gustav Adolf II, I smile, because I grew up I Lützen, the city where he was killed. Therefore I knew the stories, of course.

    WalrossWalross22 gün önce
  • I fucking LOVE

    Williams WonderWilliams Wonder25 gün önce
  • The answer is far from hitting the nail`s head. Loading a muzzle -loader takes time during which a single soldier is defenseless against cavalry-charges or massed infantry, thus he needs close support by fellow soldiers. Weapons dictate the tactics,that is all.

    Peter PimPeter Pim25 gün önce
  • That's very informative! I come from a country where these tactics were never used due to its mountainous landscape. It always seemed ridiculous to see people kill each other across a field

    Byzantine TalesByzantine Tales29 gün önce
    • what country mate

      Dog BruhDog Bruh16 gün önce
  • If early gunbattles were more about scaring one side into retreat instead of actually killing people then why not just make giant rolling explosive cannonballs, roll them into the enemy lines, and have them blow up?!

    Shawn PShawn PAylar önce
    • How will they make sure the cannon balls wont explode when reloading, midair or wont explode when its supposed to, and those were probably hella expensive with rifles being expensive already

      Nathaniel De Sagun RomanNathaniel De Sagun Roman12 gün önce
  • If no one wore armor anymore and early guns had no more range than arrows or slings but much less rate of fire then why not bring back bows?! Keep gunpowder artillery but get rid of the smoothbores...

    Shawn PShawn PAylar önce
    • It takes YEARS to master the bow, while it takes weeks to months to train as a musketeer, one bowmen dead in terms if training is losing a platoon of experience

      Nathaniel De Sagun RomanNathaniel De Sagun Roman12 gün önce
    • Benjamin Franklin considered this but it takes more training to master the bow I think

      Daniel LindsayDaniel Lindsay25 gün önce
  • Why didn't the Plug Bayonet lead to early RPGs?!

    Shawn PShawn PAylar önce
  • If feel bad for even giving this video a view.

    DMAX787DMAX787Aylar önce
  • Lol. The "why am I even watching The Patriot" line was gold.

    Sk8 N8Sk8 N8Aylar önce
    • Answer: It is a good movie

      King StarscreamKing Starscream25 gün önce
  • Why did soldiers fought in lines? Semi automatic firearm: "BECAUSE I WASN'T INVENTED IN THAT TIME!" Also, line fighting was a part of traditional formation fighting as the well known institute of FORCE MULTIPLIER from ancient times. You can shoot only one bullet with the musket and spend lot of time reloading; that's why formation was created as a force multiplier to kill more enemies where as the bow and arrow was faster to reload so the bow shooters were more doing it from a cover.

    Emir LatinovićEmir LatinovićAylar önce
  • The Patriot is horrible.

    James ScolesJames ScolesAylar önce
  • Your videos usually have a serious undertone to it but I gotta say, perfect start w/the hit markers 🤣🤣🤣

    Jonathan CostaJonathan CostaAylar önce
  • Who have watched patriot click the like button

    Bharti singhBharti singhAylar önce
  • After that they being came useless

    whylimitedwhylimitedAylar önce
  • i dont under stand .. beautiful he knows why i dont understand.

    My FirstMy FirstAylar önce
  • I'm literally 30 mins into The Patriot and I paused to google this

    Pathetic MillennialPathetic MillennialAylar önce
    • Any Mel Gibson movie is comically nationalistic... even if it doesn't take place in the US

      Liam L.E.Liam L.E.3 gün önce
    • @Quark of Theseus well in my case, i googled The Patriot after xD

      thuta naingthuta naing10 gün önce
    • One of the best comedies I've ever seen.

      Quark of TheseusQuark of Theseus13 gün önce
  • Patriot is an okay movie but I think most brits are pissed that it got made

    Arty McGee filmsArty McGee filmsAylar önce
  • I think they did this because you could not be mode down

    Rafael AlvaradoRafael AlvaradoAylar önce
  • in Asia we didn't that

    Ebra ClémentEbra ClémentAylar önce
  • Weak flanks and an assailable rear were still an issue throughout the era of linear tactics. The socket bayonet (as opposed to the plug bayonet) did not address the problems dealing with simple geometry. But it address the issues in dealing with calvary.

    robert moorerobert mooreAylar önce
  • I learned this in 5th grade so I’m using that info. They did this because old weapons were not accurate so if you fire in a line better chance to hit your opponent.

    Captain CactusCaptain CactusAylar önce
  • Your videos got me playing total war empires and company of heroes 😂

    DeanDeanAylar önce
  • Makes sense why they call it a bayonet Bay - Imagine a battlefield aka the sea O - a circle (hint hint square formation) Net - A net Translated: Square formation in a battlefield, and cavalry are charging the square formation but the infantry are repelling them like putting a net over the cavalry

    FlakeyFilmsFlakeyFilmsAylar önce
  • Google.com

    Sweet Revenge52Sweet Revenge52Aylar önce
  • Why a line? 1: Command and control - back then orders had to be shouted or relayed by drums or bugles, it was hard enough during battle in a line, mostly impossible if your spread apart 2: protection against cavalry - a regiment that stays together can form a square quicker, to protect against cavalry 3: maximizing firepower - muskets had a effective range of about 80 yards, and so a line would do the most damage to the enemy both physically and morally 4: Moral - soldiers were more willing to charge the enemy and march in the face of death if they did so together There were three main for formations for infantry 1: line - best for fighting other lines, cav can flank and break it, semi-maneuverable but hard to do over broken ground, not very vulnerable to cannon (round shot) 2: Square - a line will beat a square but horses can’t break in only ride around, not very maneuverable, semi-vulnerable to Cannon ( round shot) 3: Column - great for marching and maneuvering while only able to shoot a few muskets at once but can quickly close up to the fight against cavalry, very vulnerable to cannon (round shot)

    sir knight62sir knight62Aylar önce
  • Because they are happy to be killed in line...easy right?????? guys????😅😅😅😅😅😅

    Zarni TinZarni Tin2 aylar önce
  • Did you do this video with permission from your parents?

    Theodore BierbauerTheodore Bierbauer2 aylar önce
  • I want to thank you for telling me this info because I didn’t know this before

    Brantley HooverBrantley Hoover2 aylar önce
  • The real reason why they fought in lines is because all of their aim is trash they cant hit moving targets (except mel gibson) so they all decided to make lines to make it easier form them to hit it but hey thats just a theory a COMMENT THEORY....And cut

    Tekufu GamingTekufu Gaming2 aylar önce
    • Frick it's just a joke, I'm getting WOOSHED am i😭

      SkroozDoesSkroozDoes2 aylar önce
    • Close but no, they fought in lines cause the inaccuracy of the MUSKET, the bullet would drew away from the target

      SkroozDoesSkroozDoes2 aylar önce
  • Stupid.

    123TauruZ321123TauruZ3212 aylar önce
  • The Patriot is awful with great actors

    Tanner RuggTanner Rugg2 aylar önce
  • trvision.net/detail/video-83_h4N_lwJc.html "concetrated" I think computers make it even easier to skip letters.

    M PM P2 aylar önce
  • 2 sponsors in one video I haven't seen that before , I didn't mind just never saw that ever

    Jerel MarchJerel March2 aylar önce
  • all they had to do is give the front guys heavy metal sheilds fired their shots and lay flat after ward using the front shields to protect soldiers from the front

    CGSCGS2 aylar önce
  • Why did soldiers fight in lines? So they'd be easier to shot with machine gun.

    Marcin PasternackiMarcin Pasternacki2 aylar önce
  • I like the patriot.

    Enclave Officer Z841Enclave Officer Z8413 aylar önce
    • I do too, its not realistic... its badass

      ᘜᗅᙢᙍᖇᙘᗅᗫᗅSSᘜᗅᙢᙍᖇᙘᗅᗫᗅSSAylar önce
    • @Multi ur dead

      Enclave Officer Z841Enclave Officer Z8412 aylar önce
  • Why did soldiers fight in lines cause why the hell not

    Dominic LaconiDominic Laconi3 aylar önce
  • I have to say them big ol puffy hats did add some mass to scare people.

    Black MaskBlack Mask3 aylar önce
    • That's exactly what they were for.

      Aaron FlemingAaron FlemingAylar önce
  • Linear formations historically were for the following: 1-showing control, order, and morale; 2-assisting in re-loading with a rear echelon to re-load as the front discharged; 3-before firearms, lines allowed your mates to join in, forcing the enemy to flee, due to swords, a solid wall of shields, or formations such as the phalanx...

    thomas aquinasthomas aquinas3 aylar önce
  • Take cover.. Hello

    Brian NormanBrian Norman3 aylar önce
  • So even though guns in the 18th and 19th century has a high fire power they are not that accurate? Does that mean that mongols will still be a nightmare for europeans even if they are still using cavalry archery?

    Joel BascomJoel Bascom3 aylar önce
    • @Dod o yup that's true but remember like romans mongols of that time are very good in adapting warfare, Surely they would not fight you according to eurpean warfare and western type of formation they will go around you and then rain lots of exploding arrows on your cannons and infantry followd by a murder fest of cavalry. Trivia; did you know that at the end of 13th century they already have a rocket altilery before stalins organs was even invented?

      Joel BascomJoel Bascom2 aylar önce
  • They didn't know how actually dishonorable and stupid that it is, and how modern people now view it. Instead they viewed it as a civilized, honorable way of fighting to just line up and eventually die from a projectile. It also was due to temporary huge inaccuracies in firearms that made them wildly inaccurate. The fighting style originated in Europe and died off as soon as other nations showed how to fight off Europeans (their decapitation strikes on leadership/capitol cities no longer worked, and they couldn't fight civilized against a brutal and 'effective' enemy). People soon realized how stupid that style of fighting was even though it largely continued into the mid-1800s (even with American revolutions in riflery and more accurate rifles/shots available).

    PraetorianPraetorian3 aylar önce
  • Line = your death

    Small boy Smaller boySmall boy Smaller boy3 aylar önce
  • Didn't know Frank started a history channel...

    Locke JaweLocke Jawe3 aylar önce
  • who else got this assigned from our online teachers ?

    DurnalDurnal3 aylar önce
  • im from sweden

    AleprospelarAleprospelar3 aylar önce
  • It's not so much the lines that don't make sense. It's the fact that the front line spent a lot of time reloading. Why not just rotate to be back as the next line is loaded in ready?

    12jmlnv712jmlnv73 aylar önce
  • Line battles seemed pretty stupid.

    Random AmericanRandom American3 aylar önce
  • Because they would run out of ammo before actually hitting anything at range

    Kieran FitzgeraldKieran Fitzgerald3 aylar önce
  • Patriot is a good movie

    JaVyun TarverJaVyun Tarver3 aylar önce
Why did Soldiers Fight in Lines? | Animated History